All News
Mar 12 2014

Nature Publishes Geisler's Study on Origin of Toothed Whale Echolocation

Old Westbury, N.Y.  (March 12, 2014) – Research led by an anatomy professor at New York Institute of Technology College of Osteopathic Medicine indicates that echolocation – the sonar-like system based on high-frequency vocalizations and their echoes – was present in a 28-million-year old relative of modern-day toothed whales, dolphins, and porpoises.
Associate Professor Jonathan Geisler led the study of a new fossil species, Cotylocara macei, discovered near Charleston, SC. His findings, together with those of co-authors Matthew Colbert (University of Texas at Austin) and James Carew (College of Charleston), were published online today in Nature, the international weekly journal of science. 
“The most important conclusion of our study involves the evolution of echolocation and the complex anatomy that underlies this behavior,” said Geisler. “This was occurring at the same time that whales were diversifying in terms of feeding behavior, body size, and relative brain size.” 
Toothed whales, dolphins, and porpoises produce their high-frequency vocalizations through a constricted area in the nasal passages below the blowhole, while all other mammals, including humans, produce sounds in the larynx. The sound-producing mechanism in toothed whales is complex, with large muscles, air pockets, and bodies of fat all packed into a small area in the face. 
Scientists have long-studied how complex adaptations evolve, and new fossil discoveries often reveal that adaptations evolve in a step-wise fashion, often over long periods of geologic time.  
Geisler said their study of the skull of Cotylocara macei has led them to conclude that this whale echolocated. 
“Its dense bones and air sinuses would have helped this whale focus its vocalizations into a probing beam of sound, which likely helped it find food at night or in muddy water ocean waters,” said Geisler.
NYIT's College of Osteopathic Medicine's whale evolution website includes a new page on Cotylocara.
After detailed comparisons with living and fossil whales, Geisler and his colleagues determined that Cotylocara belonged to an extinct family of whales that split off from other whales at least 32 million years ago. Their new discovery, when viewed in the context of the entire toothed whale family tree, implies that a rudimentary form of echolocation evolved in the common ancestor of Cotylocara and other toothed whales, between 35 and 32 million years ago. Once it evolved, the fossil record indicates that there was a progressive increase in size and complexity in the air sacs and muscles that controlled the sound generating apparatus in the face. 
Cotylocara had some unique features, says Geisler, including a deep cavity on the top of its head (leading to its name, loosely translated as “cavity head”) for an air sinus that that stored air while diving and may have reflected sound generated in the face. There is also a radar-dish-like shelf of bone around the nasal openings that could have reflected sound and improved its echolocation ability.
“The anatomy of the skull is really unusual. I’ve not seen anything like this in any other whale, living or extinct” Geisler said.
Photo credits:  Top, An artistic reconstruction of the 28 million-year-old Cotylocara macei as it patrolled the shallows near present-day Charleston, South Carolina. Artwork by Carl Buell.

Bottom: The skull of the 28-million-year-old Cotylocara macei. Its anatomy and density variation indicate that this early toothed whale used echolocation to find its prey. Credit: James Carew and Mitchell Colgan.
About NYIT
New York Institute of Technology (NYIT) offers 90 degree programs, including undergraduate, graduate, and professional degrees, in more than 50 fields of study, including architecture and design; arts and sciences; education; engineering and computing sciences; health professions; management; and osteopathic medicine. A non-profit independent, private institution of higher education, NYIT has 13,000 students attending campuses on Long Island and Manhattan, online, and at its global campuses. NYIT sponsors 11 NCAA Division II programs and one Division I team.
Led by President Edward Guiliano, NYIT is guided by its mission to provide career-oriented professional education, offer access to opportunity to all qualified students, and support applications-oriented research that benefits the larger world. To date, more than 95,000 graduates have received degrees from NYIT. For more information, visit
Contact NYIT

Elizabeth Sullivan
Public Relations Strategist
.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

Elaine Iandoli
.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

Karen Marie Belnap
Global Public Relations Strategist
.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

The Box Blog
Feb 10 2016

Your Perfect Valentine’s Day Meal

Feb 09 2016

Lunch & Such: Faculty Research, Creativity, and Community at NYIT

Feb 09 2016

Scene & Heard: Upcoming Events